Algorithmic Forex

Do Robots Blow Accounts? LET’S FIGURE IT OUT! Why 90% of Trading Robots Lose Money and How to Find the Remaining 10%

Why Are There So Many Horror Stories About Robots?

«The robot blew my account in a week,» «Algorithmic trading is a scam,» «Expert Advisors only lose money»—phrases like these flood forums and chat rooms. And there’s some truth to them. The statistics are indeed ruthless: most trading robots, especially those bought «under the table» or downloaded from shady websites, lead to capital loss in the long run. But does this mean the technology of automated trading itself is unviable? Absolutely not.

It means that most people approach choosing and using a trading robot with fatal errors. They look for a «magic button» and only find a nicely packaged lottery. In this article, we will not defend all robots indiscriminately. We will conduct a rigorous, analytical breakdown of the reasons why robots «blow accounts» and provide a clear algorithm for distinguishing a working system from a financial pyramid in code.

5 Main Reasons Why Robots Really DO Blow Accounts

1. Reason: The «Ghost Strategy» Marketing Trap

You are sold a trading robot with a chart showing incredible profitability (300-500% per month) and minimal drawdown. Often, this is just a «drawn» curve created by fitting parameters to historical data (overfitting/curve fitting). The robot traded perfectly in the past, but in reality, its logic makes no economic sense.

What it looks like in practice: In a historical test (backtest) in the MetaTrader terminal, you see a perfect upward straight line. But when launched in real-time, the balance chart starts to resemble a saw pointing downward. The Expert Advisor enters trades at random moments, not considering current market logic.

2. Reason: Lack of Risk Management (or Its Imitation)

The principles of capital management are not embedded in the code of the trading bot. Dangerous techniques are often used:

• Martingale/Anti-Martingale: Increasing the lot size after a losing trade in hopes of «getting even.» Sooner or later, a series of losses occurs, depleting the deposit.
• No stop-losses or extremely wide ones. The robot «holds on» to a losing position for months.
• Fixed lot size, not tied to the deposit size. With a $1000 deposit and a 0.1 lot, one bad trade can take 10-20% of the account.

Result: Even a potentially profitable strategy turns into roulette due to incorrect position sizing.

3. Reason: «Breakdown» of Strategy When Market Regime Changes

Markets are dynamic. There are trending phases, sideways markets (flat), and periods of high volatility. Many Forex robots are tailored to one specific regime (most often—a strong trend). As soon as the market transitions into a sideways movement, the robot starts making losing trades at every local high and low.

Example: A robot that worked perfectly on the EUR/USD pair in 2020-2021 (strong trend) could have systematically «blown» all accumulated profit in 2022-2023 because the market became more chaotic.

4. Reason: Unrealistic User Expectations

The user bought a robot expecting a monthly profit of 20-30%. After the first drawdown of 10% (which is an absolute norm for most strategies), they panic: «The robot is blowing my account!»—and turn it off, locking in losses. Or they start manually interfering, breaking the system’s logic.

Psychological Aspect: A person buys into algorithmic trading but is psychologically unprepared to accept its rules—the presence of losing trades, drawdown periods, the statistical nature of the result.

5. Reason: Technical Errors and Fraud

An outright «scam.»

• Commission-Gathering Robot: Its main goal is to execute as many trades as possible so you pay spread/commission to the broker (with whom the author may have an arrangement).
• Errors in the code leading to order «freezes,» incorrect lot calculation, opening opposite positions.
• Fake reviews and forged statistics on sales websites.

How to Distinguish a «Blowing» Robot from a Working Tool in 5 Steps

Step 1: Analyze the Backtest—Don’t Believe Pretty Charts!

What to look at INSTEAD of total profit:

1. Number of Trades: Less than 100-200 trades in the tested period is statistically insignificant.
2. Maximum Drawdown (Max DD): If it exceeds 30-40%—it’s a red flag. The norm for conservative strategies is 15-25%.
3. Win Rate: It can be 40% or even 30%. This is not scary if the average winning trade is significantly larger than the average losing trade.
4. Profit Factor (PF): A key metric. PF > 1.3 is the minimum acceptable value. PF > 1.8 is good. PF > 2.5 is excellent.
5. Testing on Different Time Segments: Run the test not on the entire history but, for example, year by year. The strategy should show stability in different market periods.

Step 2: Forward Test—Real-Time Trial

Run the trading robot on a demo account for at least 2-3 months. No real deposit until this stage!

What to evaluate:

• Does the real-time balance curve roughly correspond to the backtest results?
• How does the robot behave in different market conditions (on days of important news releases, during low volatility periods)?
• Are there any technical failures, «freezes»?

Step 3: «Autopsy» of Settings and Logic

Even if you’re not a programmer, you can assess:

• Presence of clear risk management settings: Lot size (% of deposit), stop-loss, take-profit.
• Strategy description: A self-respecting developer at least outlines the logic of operation (trend-following, counter-trend, arbitrage, scalping).
• Code openness: For MQL5 Expert Advisors, you can often view the source code (in the MQL5 knowledge base). If the code is closed and not provided even after purchase—it’s a reason to be cautious.

Step 4: Check for «Martingale»

Simplest test: In the robot’s settings, find the lot parameters. If you see parameters like «Multiplier,» «Lot Increase after loss»—you are most likely looking at a martingale system. Even if it shows profit on history, in reality, it’s a ticking time bomb.

Step 5: Analyze the Community and Independent Reviews

• Look for reviews not on the seller’s website, but on independent forums (e.g., forexpeacearmy.com, specialized threads on major trading forums).
• Ask experienced acquaintances about the robot.
• Check the developer’s history on MQL5.com: how many years in the market, what other products they’ve released, how they communicate in comments.

Which Robots «Blow» Most Often? TOP 3 Dangerous Types

1. Forex Scalper-Martingales.
   • Promises: «100-200 pips per day without a stop-loss!»
   • Reality: High trade frequency with huge spreads, lot multiplication after a loss. Blows an account in a few unsuccessful series.
2. «Holy Grails» with Guaranteed Profitability.
   • Promises: «87% winning trades, 50% monthly return.»
   • Reality: Results achieved through overfitting. Don’t work in real-time. Sold for huge sums ($5000+).
3. Robots for Binary Options (and Crypto Analogues).
   • Promises: «Signals with 90% accuracy.»
   • Reality: Most often, these are simple indicators repackaged as a «robot.» Have no relation to quantitative trading. Operate on the «guess the direction» principle.

Do Working Robots Even Exist?

Yes. But they don’t look like a fairy tale. Their distinguishing features:

1. Modest but stable results. The goal is 5-20% per month, not 100%.
2. The developer talks about risks and drawdowns. The description has a «Risks» section.
3. The strategy has an economic or statistical logic: following trends, arbitrage, statistical pairs, following «smart money» (COT report).
4. There is a long history of real work (not tests!) on the developer’s accounts or in MQL5 signals.
5. The robot requires competent setup and periodic optimization for current market conditions.

Your Safety Strategy—How to Prevent a Robot from «Blowing» Your Account

Even with the most reliable robot, you need your own safety system:

1. Don’t entrust all capital to one robot. Split your deposit. Run the robot only on part of the funds (e.g., 20-30%).
2. Use a Virtual Private Server (VPS). This protects against your computer and internet failures.
3. Set «hard» external limits:
   • Daily stop-loss (e.g., -5% of the robot’s account).
   • Weekly stop-loss (e.g., -15%).
   • Maximum number of trades per day.
   • These limits are set not in the robot’s settings, but at the account level or using a separate controller script.
4. Never use leverage higher than 1:10 for conservative strategies and 1:50 for aggressive ones. High leverage is the main ally of «blowouts.»
5. Regular audit. Spend 15 minutes weekly analyzing a report: total profit, current drawdown, any technical failures.

Robots Don’t Blow Accounts. Expectations and Ignorance Do.

The phrase «robots blow accounts» is a half-truth more dangerous than a lie. It shifts responsibility from the trader to soulless code. In reality, it’s not robots that blow accounts, but:

• The desire for easy profit.
• Lack of basic knowledge on how to test a strategy.
• Willingness to believe in a fairy tale.
• Inability to manage risks.

Algorithmic trading is a powerful, professional technology. It requires no less knowledge than manual trading. But this knowledge is of a different kind: not how to guess a reversal, but how to build, test, and protect a system.

Your action plan if you’re afraid of a «blowout»:

1. Forget about returns above 30% per month as the main criterion.
2. Start learning how to read backtest reports (Profit Factor, Max DD).
3. Spend 3 times more time on forward testing than on searching for a robot.
4. Start small: launch the robot with 1/10 of your planned deposit.
5. Accept as an axiom: Any, even the best strategy, will have drawdown periods. Your task is to survive them, not to panic.

A working trading robot is not a gamble, but a boring, repetitive process of extracting statistical edge. And it is precisely in this «boredom» that its true power and protection from the notorious «blowout» lie.

Subscribe to the Telegram channel: @Algo_Forex_Trade

Study the materials on the official website: algoforexsystem.com

To get advice, write to me in private messages: @Anton_Algorithmic